Affiliate Disclosure
This post contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend books I’ve personally read and genuinely enjoyed.
I didn’t go into Remarkably Bright Creatures expecting to love it.
Honestly, the premise sounded… odd. A novel partially narrated by an octopus? It felt like one of those books people hype up as “quirky and charming,” but that doesn’t always land for me. Still, so many people whose reading taste I trust kept saying the same thing: just give it a chance.
So I did—but I made one specific choice that I think mattered. I listened to this book on audio.
What I Expected vs. What I Actually Experienced
What I expected was a novelty-driven story that leaned too hard on its “cute” concept. I assumed the octopus narration would either feel gimmicky or distract from the emotional core of the book.
What I actually got was a surprisingly grounded, emotionally thoughtful story about grief, loneliness, and the slow ways people find connection again.
The octopus—Marcellus—ended up being one of the strongest parts of the book, not because he was clever or funny (though he is both), but because his perspective added clarity rather than chaos. His voice brought structure to the story instead of pulling focus from it.
How It Felt to Read (and Listen To)
This is not a fast-paced book. It unfolds patiently, and at times it asks you to trust that things are building even when it doesn’t feel like much is happening on the surface.
On audio, that patience worked in its favor.
The narrator for Marcellus was, in my opinion, perfectly cast. His sections felt calm, observant, and quietly sharp—never overdone. I genuinely believe the audiobook format made it easier to stay engaged during the slower sections, especially early on when the story is still finding its rhythm.
By the time everything started coming together, I understood why people kept saying, “Just keep going.” The emotional payoff isn’t dramatic or explosive—it’s subtle, but deeply satisfying.
Who This Book Is For (and Who It’s Not)
This book is likely a great fit if you:
- Enjoy character-driven stories over plot-heavy ones
- Are open to unconventional narrators when they serve the story
- Don’t mind a slower build if the emotional payoff feels earned
- Like books that sit with grief and healing without being heavy-handed
This book may not be for you if:
- You prefer fast-moving plots or constant tension
- You’re looking for something suspenseful or high-stakes
- You struggle with books that take time to fully come together
Final Thoughts
I’m really glad I gave Remarkably Bright Creatures a chance—especially on audio. It ended up being one of those books that quietly earns your affection rather than demanding it upfront.
If the premise sounds strange to you, I understand. I felt the same way. But if you’re willing to be patient and let the story unfold, there’s a good chance it will surprise you in the best way.
