Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only share books I’ve personally read and genuinely loved.
Why I Picked Up My Oxford Year
I almost never read a book because of a movie trailer — but this time I did. When I saw that the Netflix film was based on My Oxford Year, I decided I wanted to read the book first. I expected a light, maybe slightly cheesy romance set in England. Something enjoyable, but forgettable.
That is not what happened.
What I Expected Going In
I expected:
- A predictable romance
- Some charming Oxford scenery
- A “nice” love story I’d enjoy and move on from
I also expected to enjoy the movie more than the book — because honestly, that’s usually how it goes for me.
What I Actually Got
This book completely blindsided me.
I very rarely give five-star ratings. I’m picky. But My Oxford Year earned it — and I still can’t fully explain why it hit me as hard as it did. It was a little corny at times. I fully understand why some people don’t like it.
But it tugged at something real.
The twist was not what I expected — at all. And it became the first book that has ever made me cry. Not misty-eyed. Actually cry.
When it ended, I was angry — not because it was bad, but because I wasn’t ready to let the characters go. I felt genuinely connected to them and invested in their growth.
What Made It So Powerful for Me
What stayed with me most was:
- Watching Ella balance her professional life in America with her personal life in England
- Seeing how much the characters change, not just romantically, but emotionally
- The way the story quietly asks you to think about choice, timing, and what you’re willing to give up
This book met me exactly where I was in my life at the time — and sometimes that’s all it takes for a story to stay with you.
The Movie vs. the Book (Honest Take)
I was so excited to watch the movie afterward — and honestly? I was mad the entire time.
If you haven’t read the book, the movie is… fine. But if you have read it, the changes are frustrating. Names were changed for no real reason. Certain emotional moments didn’t land the same. The book was simply more powerful.
This is one of those rare cases where I’d strongly recommend:
Read the book first. Always.
Final Thoughts
I don’t think My Oxford Year is perfect. But it’s real. Emotional. And quietly devastating in the best way.
It’s the kind of book that:
- Sneaks up on you
- Hits harder than you expect
- Lingers after the last page
And sometimes, that’s exactly the book you need.
