Affiliate Disclosure
This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend books I’ve personally read and can honestly talk about.
I read The Crash during a full-on Freida McFadden phase — the kind where you tear through book after book because her thrillers are fast, addictive, and hard to put down. And honestly, that context matters for this review.
Expectation:
Another top-tier, can’t-stop, edge-of-your-seat Freida thriller.
Reality:
A solid, engaging read — just not my favorite from her.
I gave The Crash 3 out of 5 stars, which for me is still a good rating. I’m glad I read it, I’d recommend it to the right reader, but it’s not one I’ll reread or think about long-term the way some of her other books have stuck with me.
The premise pulled me in immediately, and I liked how the story unfolded from different perspectives. That said, there were moments where it felt like a lot of storylines were happening at once. Everything does come together in the end, but while I was reading, I occasionally found myself trying to remember details that had been mentioned earlier and not revisited for a while.
Because I listened to this one fairly quickly, that didn’t end up being a huge issue for me — but I could see it being harder to follow if you’re someone who reads a little, puts the book down, and comes back days later.
Another thing I noticed is that I sometimes struggle when a story puts you directly inside the mind of characters making irrational decisions. I know that’s often the point in thrillers — especially this one — but it can make me feel frustrated rather than fully immersed. It worked for the story, it just isn’t always my personal favorite reading experience.
Overall, The Crash is good, not great (for me), and still worth reading if you enjoy Freida McFadden’s style. I wouldn’t discourage anyone from picking it up — just go in knowing it’s more of a solid entry than a standout if you’ve already read a lot of her work.
